Trip to Alcatraz

Written by Martin Consunji, Mark Koskei, Janice Lan, and Michael Su

On February 15th 2011, we visited Alcatraz as part of our course on tourism and authenticity. As first time visitors, we each had different expectations based on its depiction in movies and popular culture. Janice had never seen any movies about Alcatraz before, so she did not have any preconceived notions and did not expect much more than a prison on a small island with a moderately interesting history. On the other hand, Mark, Martin, and Michael had previously watched movies about Alcatraz, such as The Rock, Escape from Alcatraz, and X-Men: The Last Stand. Thus, they all had high expectations of Alcatraz as a glorified, intense, complex, and large maximum security prison.

Upon arrival on the dock of “The Rock” at around 11 o’clock, we were met by friendly park rangers who gave us a brief introduction to Alcatraz, safety instructions, and tour options. Park ranger John informed us that Alcatraz only became a national park because of its military history. Ironically, most tourists, us included, chose to embark on the audio tour of the prison rather than exploring the other different historical layers of Alcatraz.

Overall, we thought that the audio tour was very well done. The navigation was simple and easy, the narrators were clear and interesting, and the sound effects enhanced the tour and made the experience feel more authentic. Additionally, former correctional officers and inmates spoke of their personal experiences, which strengthened the credibility of the audio tour.

The tour took us through a good amount of history of the island’s prison. From detailed descriptions of the lives of the inmates to suspenseful escape stories, the audio tour kept our interest throughout the 45 minutes. We were able to see different cells, the dining and recreational areas, and even the pipes behind the cells through which some prisoners escaped.

Janice felt like her expectations were met – she learned some interesting history and got to see what the inside of a prison looked like. The tour was obviously not completely authentic, as there were no inmates, but she did not expect much more than what the tour offered. The rest of our group felt let down because they had high expectations from the glorified depictions in movies. Nevertheless, everyone enjoyed the trip and appreciated the opportunity to visit Alcatraz.

This entry was posted in Stanford Tourism Class. Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Trip to Alcatraz

  1. Angela Chou says:

    I think it’s interesting to see how you guys felt differently about the trip considering some of you guys have seen movies filmed on the rock. The expectation definitely shaped the way you viewed the audio tour and the visit in general.

  2. Sally M. says:

    You have some really nice pictures that go along well with the text.

  3. Alexandra To says:

    I am also interested in your different responses to your visit. I understand how those who have seen movies would expect a more glorified Alcatraz, I did to some degree, but what specific aspects did you expect to see and what specifically was disappointing?

  4. Sally M. says:

    You have so really nice pictures that go along well with the text.

  5. Alex says:

    I also thought the audio tour was very well done and I really enjoyed it. It was cool to hear the different persepectives of the various narrators, but I sometimes had trouble following who was speaking and remembering that person’s role at Alcatraz. A friend of mine recommended the movie Birdman of Alcatraz. I think we all might enjoy it now that we know about the actual “Birdman,” inmate Robert Stroud.

  6. Cameron Wilson says:

    I thought it was interesting that even though your commentary isn’t particularly grim, your pictures were quite depressing. The writer seems to be content with the fact that Janice had a good experience and everyone thought the audio tour to be interesting and informing. Yet, the pictures create an ambiance of darkness and despondency despite the fact that the writing is optimistic and cheerful.

  7. Mark K says:

    From the movies, Especially X men, I expected a much larger place, and thought the buildings would be in a better condition. I also expected more activities to be going on as depicted in the movies but I now realize how this was far fetched. Perhaps the space felt smaller since most of the buildings were closed down and visitors were only allowed to visit/enter a few.

  8. Kate says:

    So in what ways did you expect Alcatraz to be different (based on your preconceived movie notions)?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s